German lay body ZdK defends same-sex blessings and reform agenda despite Pope Leo XIV’s concerns over doctrine and unity in the Church.
Newsroom (13/05/2026 Gaudium Press ) The Central Committee of German Catholics (ZdK), one of the most influential lay organizations in Germany and a driving force behind the controversial “Synodal Path,” has reaffirmed its support for the continued blessing of same-sex couples and those in what the Church traditionally considers “irregular situations.” The position was articulated during the group’s spring plenary assembly opening in Würzburg, underscoring growing tensions between reform-minded sectors in Germany and the Vatican.
Irme Stetter-Karp, president of the ZdK, publicly dismissed concerns raised by Pope Leo XIV, asserting that they are “unfounded.” She argued that the liturgical framework in question clearly distinguishes between sacramental marriage and non-sacramental blessing ceremonies, thus maintaining doctrinal boundaries while expanding pastoral inclusion.
Continued Push for Same-Sex Blessings
At the heart of the dispute is a document developed jointly by ZdK representatives and members of the German Bishops’ Conference within the Synodal Path process. The guide outlines how blessing ceremonies for same-sex couples and others in irregular unions may be carried out in practice.
Stetter-Karp emphasized the importance of broad implementation. “I hope this guide for blessing celebrations will continue to be used to bless same-sex couples and couples in so-called irregular situations in as many places as possible,” she stated.
Her remarks came in direct response to recent signals from Pope Leo XIV, who has reiterated the Church’s teaching on marriage and sexual morality and expressed reservations about certain pastoral initiatives emerging from Germany. The Pope has consistently stressed the importance of doctrinal fidelity and warned against developments that could undermine the unity of the global Church.
Synodal Path Maintains Reform Momentum
The ZdK’s position reflects the continuing momentum of the Synodal Path, a reform process launched in Germany that has proposed significant changes in areas ranging from sexual ethics to ecclesial governance. Despite repeated warnings from the Holy See over the past several years, German reform advocates appear determined to press forward.
Stetter-Karp’s speech underscored that determination, signaling that the progressive wing of the German Church is not prepared to scale back its ambitions. The Vatican has repeatedly voiced concern about proposals tied to the Synodal Path, particularly those involving moral teaching, authority structures, and the sacraments.
Pope Leo XIV has, since the early days of his pontificate, cautioned against the emergence of “separate national paths” that could weaken ecclesial communion. His interventions have sought to preserve doctrinal unity across the universal Church, even as local contexts call for pastoral adaptation.
Renewed Advocacy for the Female Diaconate
Beyond the debate over blessings, the ZdK is also intensifying its calls for structural changes within the Church—especially regarding the role of women. Stetter-Karp once again urged progress toward the introduction of a female diaconate, expressing disappointment with recent developments in Rome.
While acknowledging some positive remarks from Pope Leo XIV about the Church engaging broader societal issues, she criticized the absence of concrete movement on women’s ordination to the diaconate.
“The results of the Vatican study group on the female diaconate don’t really encourage me,” she said. “Once again we are told that, in the current state of affairs, women cannot access the diaconate.”
Her remarks reflect ongoing frustration among reform advocates, who see the issue as central to broader questions about equality and participation within the Church.
Broader Social and Political Criticism
Stetter-Karp also used the platform to address issues beyond ecclesial reform, extending her critique to German public policy. She criticized potential reductions in social spending, cuts to international aid, and what she described as insufficient commitment to climate policy.
Additionally, she warned of what she termed a growing social “fatigue” regarding the Church’s response to sexual abuse, urging continued vigilance and sustained reforms to ensure accountability and protection for victims.
A Church at a Crossroads
The developments in Würzburg highlight the widening gap between segments of the German Catholic community and the Vatican. As the ZdK continues to advocate for reforms in doctrine, governance, and pastoral practice, the Holy See remains firm in its emphasis on unity and adherence to established teaching.
With both sides holding entrenched positions, the debate over the future direction of the Church—particularly in Germany—shows no signs of resolution. Instead, it continues to evolve as one of the most significant internal discussions facing global Catholicism today.
- Raju Hasmukh with files from Infovaticana
Related Images:
