Cardinal Fernández to meet SSPX leader amid group’s controversial plan to consecrate bishops without papal mandate, risking renewed schism.
Newsroom (05/02/2026 Gaudium Press ) Cardinal Víctor Manuel Fernández, head of the Vatican’s Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith (DDF), will meet next week with Fr. Davide Pagliarani, superior general of the Society of St. Pius X (SSPX). The meeting follows the traditionalist group’s stunning announcement that it plans to consecrate new bishops in July—without papal approval—a step that could ignite an ecclesial crisis reminiscent of the 1988 Lefebvrist schism.
Pagliarani, who made the announcement on Feb. 2, said the decision came after his August 2025 request for an audience with Pope Leo XIV and after receiving a recent Vatican letter that he described as failing to address the society’s concerns. According to Cardinal Fernández, that letter was from the DDF and “merely responded negatively to the possibility of proceeding now with new episcopal ordinations.”
“We have been exchanging letters in recent times,” Fernández told The Pillar. “Next week I will meet with Fr. Pagliarani in the DDF to try and find a fruitful path of dialogue.”
History of Strained Relations
The SSPX was founded in 1970 by French Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre in response to theological and liturgical changes introduced by the Second Vatican Council. In 1988, Lefebvre illicitly consecrated four bishops, resulting in his excommunication by Pope John Paul II for schism. Over the following decades, the SSPX was often regarded as estranged from full communion with the Catholic Church, though dialogue has persisted.
Of the four bishops Lefebvre consecrated, only Bishop Bernard Fellay, 67, and Bishop Alfonso de Galarreta, 69, remain alive. Bishop Bernard Tissier de Mallerais died in 2024, and Bishop Richard Williamson—expelled from the SSPX in 2012—died in 2025.
The SSPX statement on Feb. 2 said Pagliarani had sought to present the society’s situation “in a filial manner” to the pope but that “the letter recently received from the Holy See does not in any way respond to our requests.”
Should the group proceed with the ordinations without papal mandate, canon law dictates automatic excommunication for those involved—both the consecrating bishops and the men they ordain—signaling what would be a fresh act of schism. Such a move could return Vatican relations with the SSPX to their most strained level since 1988.
Episodes of Reconciliation and Friction
In recent decades, the Vatican has attempted to navigate the SSPX’s irregular status. In 2009, Pope Benedict XVI lifted the excommunications incurred in 1988, though he clarified the society still lacked canonical status and its priests could not licitly exercise ministry. Efforts continued through frequent negotiations aimed at regularizing the group’s relationship with the Church.
Under Pope Francis, that dialogue endured even as theological divisions persisted. Francis granted SSPX priests faculties to hear confessions during the 2015 Year of Mercy—later extended indefinitely—and, in 2017, permitted bishops to authorize SSPX priests to witness Catholic marriages. Those concessions sought to ensure sacramental validity for Catholics who attend SSPX chapels.
That same year, Archbishop Guido Pozzo, then secretary of the Vatican’s Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei (since suppressed), hinted that the SSPX might one day be granted a canonical structure akin to a personal prelature—similar to that of Opus Dei. Despite such progress, institutional reconciliation has remained elusive.
Tension and Hope Ahead of Meeting
Cardinal Fernández’s planned meeting with Pagliarani will reportedly involve only the two leaders, suggesting a confidential and possibly decisive exchange. Previous discussions also included veteran SSPX bishops Fellay and de Galarreta, and on the Vatican side, Cardinal Kurt Koch, head of the Dicastery for Promoting Christian Unity, and Archbishop Pozzo.
Observers say any unauthorized consecration this summer would undo years of cautious rapprochement. The Vatican has increasingly referred to the SSPX as existing in a state of “imperfect communion” rather than full schism, signaling that ties—though strained—still hold canonical and theological weight.
The SSPX currently claims around 700 priests worldwide and says some 600,000 Catholics attend its Masses, including about 25,000 regular attendees in the United States. Many dioceses, however, still warn Catholics against affiliation with SSPX chapels due to their irregular ecclesial status.
As the DDF prepares to host next week’s dialogue, Vatican officials stress that the goal remains reconciliation rather than rupture. Yet with the SSPX poised to move ahead with bishop consecrations in defiance of Rome, the long-fractured bond between the Holy See and Lefebvre’s followers faces one of its greatest tests in decades.
- Raju Hasmukh with files from The Pillar
Related Images:
