Toronto’s Archdiocese urges Catholics to back Bill C-218, opposing 2027 MAiD expansion for those with mental illness alone.
Newsroom (17/03/2026 Gaudium Press)As Parliament readies for another divisive debate on Canada’s assisted dying laws, the Archdiocese of Toronto has launched a sweeping campaign aimed at stopping next year’s planned expansion of medical assistance in dying (MAiD) to individuals living solely with mental illness.
The initiative, titled Help Not Harm, mobilizes Canada’s largest Catholic community to support Bill C-218, The Right to Recover Act, which seeks to make it a criminal offence to provide MAiD when mental illness is the sole underlying condition. If passed, the legislation would clarify that such mental health disorders cannot be classified as a “grievous and irremediable medical condition” — a key eligibility threshold under Canada’s euthanasia framework.
Mobilizing the Faithful
Central to the campaign is a call for parishioners to visit helpnotharmcanada.ca, where participants can fill out a form to automatically generate a letter to Prime Minister Mark Carney, Minister of Justice Sean Fraser, and their local Member of Parliament. The site allows users to send the prepared message or personalize it before submission.
Messaging featured on the website emphasizes the moral and clinical complexities of permitting assisted dying for mental illness. It argues that expanding MAiD in this way “sends a conflicting message at a time when Canada is investing in suicide prevention and crisis support.” Another key point warns that “there is no medical consensus on when a mental health condition is truly untreatable, making accurate and ethical assessments extremely difficult.”
Cardinal Leo’s Pastoral Appeal
In a pastoral letter announcing the campaign, Cardinal Frank Leo, Archbishop of Toronto, urged the faithful to anchor their response in compassion and care. “The Catholic response to the mental health crisis must be love, solidarity, and a steadfast commitment to care,” he wrote. “We are called to offer help, not harm; hope, not despair; protection, not abandonment.”
Leo is expected to follow the public launch with direct correspondence to Carney, Fraser, and all MPs representing constituencies within the Archdiocese, pressing them to vote in favour of the legislation introduced last summer by Conservative MP Tamara Jansen.
“Advocating for laws that protect and promote life is a meaningful expression of our Catholic faith in action — most especially during this Lenten journey, a time of prayer, fasting and almsgiving,” Leo added. “Let us pray for our elected officials, that they may be guided by wisdom and courage. May we also hold close in prayer all who live with mental illness and their families, that they may receive compassionate care and renewed hope.”
Legislative Stakes and Political Landscape
The Archdiocese’s campaign comes as Bill C-218 approaches a crucial juncture. The bill’s second hour of debate and second reading vote are expected during the week of April 13–17 — a period that also coincides with three federal by-elections in Scarborough Southwest, University-Rosedale, and Terrebonne. Depending on those results, the Liberal government could regain a majority just days before the vote.
C-218 is effectively the successor to Bill C-314, a similar motion introduced by retired MP Ed Fast, which was narrowly defeated in October 2023 by a vote of 167–150. That bill had drawn unanimous support from the Conservative, NDP, and Green parties, alongside eight dissenting Liberal MPs, but ultimately failed due to strong opposition from most Liberals and the Bloc Québécois.
Given the current composition of the House of Commons, supporters of C-218 estimate they will again need at least 24 Liberal MPs to cross the floor if the bill is to advance to the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights.
During the first hour of debate in December 2025, both Liberal and Bloc Québécois representatives signalled hesitation, favouring a wait for recommendations from the Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying, which is reviewing safeguards and future eligibility criteria.
Neil MacCarthy, Director of Public Relations and Communications for the Archdiocese of Toronto, told The Catholic Register that the Church is following those proceedings closely. “We would welcome the opportunity to participate in the process or in any discussions relating to euthanasia legislation in our country,” he wrote.
Faith Meets Public Policy
The Help Not Harm campaign is unfolding across parishes through March and April, with posters, prayer resources, and announcements integrated into Mass schedules. Its timing underscores the Archdiocese’s intent to pair religious conviction with civic engagement as the country approaches a highly consequential decision.
By invoking both compassion and democratic agency, the campaign’s architects aim to amplify a simple message ahead of next year’s policy shift: that care, not killing, should be Canada’s moral compass in addressing mental illness.
- Raju Hasmukh with files from Catholic Register
Related Images:
