PHILADELPHIA, USA (Tuesday, January 15, 2019, Gaudium Press) Judges in California and Pennsylvania have issued injunctions against a Trump administration rule that would allow the Little Sisters of the Poor and similar groups to claim a religious exemption against the Department of Health and Human Services’ so-called contraception mandate.
Little Sisters of the Poor
outside the Supreme Court in March 2016, for the Zubik v. Burwell case. (Addie Mena/CNA)
Judge Haywood Gilliam of the U.S. District Court for Northern California issued a preliminary injunction Jan. 13 that affects 13 states plus the District of Columbia in the case State of California v. HHS. Gillam declined to issue the nationwide injunction requested by the plaintiffs, the attorneys general of several states, led by California.
Responding to the ruling, Mark Rienzi, president of the Becket law group, said Sunday’s decision “will allow politicians to threaten the rights of religious women like the Little Sisters of the Poor,” whom Becket represents.
On Monday, U.S. district Judge Wendy Beetlestone issued a nationwide injunction blocking the same rule in her decision for the case Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Trump.
“We never wanted this fight, and we regret that after a long legal battle it is still not over,” said Mother Loraine Marie Maguire of the Little Sisters of the Poor.
“We pray that we can once again devote our lives to our ministry of serving the elderly poor, as we have for over 175 years, without being forced to violate our faith.”
In October 2017, the Trump administration issued a new rule that would expand the eligibility of groups to claim religious exemptions to the contraceptive mandate. The new rule was set to go into effect on Monday.
California Attorney General Xavier Becerra filed suit against the Trump administration over the new rule shortly after it was announced and was joined by 12 other states and the District of Columbia.
The Little Sisters of the Poor, and many other religious-based organizations, were not eligible under previous religious exemptions to the mandate since they do not exclusively employ or serve people of their religion.
The sisters argue that forcing them to offer an insurance plan that provides birth-control pills and devices to their employees would violate their religious beliefs.
Rienzi said in a statement Monday that the Little Sisters will return to court to fight the injunctions.
“Now the nuns are forced to keep fighting this unnecessary lawsuit to protect their ability to focus on caring for the poor,” said Rienzi.
“We are confident these decisions will be overturned.”
Source Catholic News Agency